Whether you’re just curious or seriously thinking about selling, “What’s my house worth?” is the first question most homeowners ask. You can get a pretty good idea on your own before you ever pay for an appraisal or call an agent. Here’s how to estimate your home’s value in Spokane, Coeur d’Alene or the Tri-Cities, and why the number on a website may not match what a buyer will actually pay.
Start by thinking like an appraiser
Appraisers look at a fairly standard list of things:
- Bedrooms and bathrooms
- Finished square footage, and whether a basement is finished
- Lot size and usability
- Age of the home and its major systems: roof, furnace, water heater, electrical, plumbing
- Overall condition and updates
- Location: the neighborhood, school boundaries, traffic, nearby amenities and access to major roads
- Special features like a garage or shop, views, or water frontage
Walk your house with that list in hand and be honest about where it stands.
Find the right comparable sales
“Comps” are recently sold homes similar to yours. They’re the backbone of any good value estimate. To pick good ones:
- Stay close. Same neighborhood if you can. In Spokane, a few blocks can make a real difference, for example moving between parts of the South Hill, or crossing an arterial in North Spokane. In Coeur d’Alene, distance to the lake and downtown matters a lot.
- Stay recent. Sales from the last three to six months are best. Markets change.
- Match the basics. Similar size, age, style, bedroom and bathroom count and lot.
- Use sold prices, not list prices. Asking prices tell you what sellers hope for. Sold prices tell you what buyers paid.
- Match condition. A fully remodeled house down the street is not a fair comp for a house with its original 1960s kitchen.
Listing sites show recent sales, and county assessor websites have property details. Keep in mind that the assessed value on your tax statement is not the same as market value.
A note for North Idaho
Idaho doesn’t require sale prices to be made public the way many states do. That means online value estimates in Kootenai County often have less sales data to work from, and they can be further off. Local agents and buyers who see actual sale prices usually have a better read.
Use price per square foot as a rough check
Price per square foot is a handy shortcut:
- For each comp, divide the sold price by its finished square footage.
- Average those numbers.
- Multiply the average by your home’s finished square footage.
For example, if three similar homes sold for an average of $250 per square foot and your house has 1,600 finished square feet, that points to around $400,000. Treat it as a starting point. Price per square foot works best when the comps really are similar, and it gets less reliable for unusual homes, big lots or very large or very small houses.
Adjust for what makes your house different
Then adjust up or down:
- Up for recent updates like a newer roof, remodeled kitchen or bath, new windows or siding, a big garage or shop, a great yard, or a view.
- Down for needed repairs, dated finishes, a busy street, a steep driveway that’s tough in winter, or anything a buyer’s inspector will flag.
Be honest here. Condition is where most homeowners overestimate.
Why online estimates miss, especially on older homes
Automated estimates like the Zestimate are a fine starting point, but they’re only as good as the data behind them. They often miss when:
- Public records are wrong or outdated. Wrong square footage, bedroom count or lot size throws the number off.
- The computer can’t see condition. An algorithm doesn’t know whether your house has knob-and-tube wiring, an old roof or a brand new kitchen. That matters a lot in older Spokane neighborhoods where houses on the same block can range from original to fully remodeled.
- The home is unique. Acreage, lake property, cabins, manufactured homes on land and homes with shops don’t have many true comps.
- There’s not much sales data, as in North Idaho.
When to get a professional opinion
- Comparative market analysis. Most agents will prepare one for free if you’re considering listing.
- Appraisal. A licensed appraiser gives an independent opinion of value. It costs money, but it’s useful for divorce, estates, buyouts between family members and refinancing.
- A cash offer. If your house needs work, an as-is offer tells you what it’s worth to a buyer today, without repairs.
What about future value?
Homes often gain value over time, but there’s no guarantee. Appreciation varies a lot by neighborhood and market cycle. Also keep in mind that an aging house needs more repairs as the years go by, which eats into the gain. If you’ve owned for a long time and big repairs are coming, it may be a good time to think about selling.
Get a real number on your house
If you’d like to know what your house is worth as-is, we’ll look at it and give you a fair cash offer, usually within 24 hours, with no obligation, and we’re happy to explain how we got there. We buy as-is, with no fees or commissions, and we pay the closing costs.
Backyard Home Buyers is local and family-owned. Both owners were born and raised in the Inland Northwest, and we’ve done over 500 deals since 2019 in Spokane, Coeur d’Alene and the Tri-Cities. Send us your address or call (509) 461-9079.


